Contractor vs Permanent Employee Calculator 2025/26

Compare your contractor day rate to an equivalent permanent salary. See the true take-home comparison including benefits, pension, holiday and all deductions.

Contractor vs Permanent Comparison

Contractor (Ltd Company) Route

Gross annual revenue
Less allowable expenses
Director salary drawn
Corporation tax (19%)
Net dividends (after dividend tax)
Contractor annual take-home

Permanent Employee Route

Gross salary
Income tax
Employee NI
Permanent net take-home
Employer pension contribution
Other benefits value
Total compensation package

Comparison

Take-home advantage (contractor vs perm)
Permanent day rate equivalent (salary ÷ 230)
Breakeven day rate (to match perm total comp)

Based on 2025/26 tax rates. Contractor route assumes outside IR35, Ltd company with optimal salary/dividend extraction. Director salary set at personal allowance (£12,570). Does not account for all individual circumstances — consult a qualified accountant.

How to Compare Contractor and Permanent Pay

The headline day rate is not the same as take-home pay. A £500/day contract rate sounds lucrative, but once you account for non-billable days, business expenses, accountancy fees and the absence of employer pension and paid holiday, the true comparison is more nuanced.

Use this calculator to run both scenarios side by side with 2025/26 tax rates and NI thresholds so you make your decision on real numbers.

The Contractor Ltd Company Route

Operating through a Ltd company allows you to split income between salary and dividends. A salary at the personal allowance threshold (£12,570) means no income tax and no NI on that portion. Remaining profits after corporation tax (19%) are extracted as dividends, taxed at 8.75% (basic rate) or 33.75% (higher rate) — lower than the equivalent employment income tax rates.

The Permanent Employee Package

A permanent role offers more than just gross salary. Employer pension contributions (3% minimum under auto-enrolment, often 5–10%), paid holiday, private health insurance, income protection, and enhanced maternity/paternity pay are all real financial benefits that contractors must fund themselves.

The Breakeven Day Rate Concept

The breakeven day rate is the minimum day rate at which contracting produces the same net financial outcome as the permanent role. Below the breakeven rate, the permanent role is financially superior when benefits are included. Above it, contracting pays more — but you must value the additional flexibility appropriately for your circumstances.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I compare a contractor day rate to a permanent salary? +
Multiply your day rate by working days per year (typically 230 accounting for holidays and admin time). Subtract allowable business expenses, then apply the optimal Ltd company extraction strategy — salary to the personal allowance (£12,570) plus dividends. Compare net take-home to the permanent salary after income tax and employee NI.
Why use 230 working days for contractors? +
Contractors typically lose 20 days to holiday, 8 to bank holidays, and up to 15 days to marketing, business development and admin. 230 days is a common industry benchmark. Some contractors in high-demand roles bill 240+ days; others in competitive markets may bill fewer than 200.
What is the optimal Ltd company salary in 2025/26? +
The most common strategy is to pay yourself the personal allowance (£12,570) — no income tax and no employer NI at this level. Remaining profits after corporation tax are extracted as dividends. Some contractors use the NI secondary threshold (£9,100) if they have other income.
Does IR35 affect this calculation? +
Yes — significantly. If you are inside IR35, you are taxed as a deemed employee. Income is subject to income tax and NI as if employed, removing the dividend and corporation tax advantage. An inside IR35 day rate needs to be considerably higher to match an outside IR35 equivalent.
What counts as an allowable business expense? +
Allowable expenses include professional indemnity and public liability insurance, accountancy fees, professional subscriptions, business phone and broadband (proportion), IT equipment wholly for work, travel to client sites, and training directly related to current contracts.
How do permanent employee benefits affect the comparison? +
Permanent roles often include employer pension contributions (3–10% of salary), 28 days paid holiday (worth roughly 10.8% of salary), private health insurance (£500–£2,000/year), and income protection. These can add 20–35% above gross salary to the total compensation package value.
What is the breakeven day rate? +
The breakeven day rate is the minimum contract day rate needed to match a permanent role's net take-home plus benefits. It accounts for contractor overheads, benefits gaps, unpaid holiday and self-funded pension. It is typically 25–40% above the raw salary-equivalent day rate.
Can I contribute to a pension from my Ltd company? +
Yes. Employer pension contributions from your Ltd company are an allowable business expense, reducing corporation tax. You can contribute up to £60,000 gross per year (or 100% of earnings if lower). This is often more tax-efficient than personal contributions.
What is the 2025/26 dividend allowance? +
The dividend allowance is £500 for 2025/26. Dividends above this threshold are taxed at 8.75% (basic rate), 33.75% (higher rate) or 39.35% (additional rate). The reduction from £2,000 has significantly reduced the contractor Ltd company advantage at higher income levels.
What overheads should contractors budget for annually? +
Typical annual overheads: accountancy (£1,000–£2,500), professional indemnity insurance (£300–£1,500), public liability (£150–£400), professional subscriptions (£200–£500), business banking (£100–£300). Total: approximately £2,000–£5,000 per year.
Do I get SSP or maternity pay as a Ltd company contractor? +
Ltd company directors are eligible for Statutory Sick Pay (£116.75/week for up to 28 weeks) and Statutory Maternity/Paternity Pay, but amounts are far lower than occupational sick pay or enhanced maternity/paternity pay available to permanent employees — a significant benefit gap to factor in.
Is contracting worth it financially? +
For roles commanding £350+/day outside IR35, contracting typically produces higher net income than an equivalent permanent role. However, weigh the premium against lack of employment security, no paid holiday, no employer pension, and the admin overhead of running a Ltd company. Breakeven calculations like this one help you make an informed decision.