Compare AIA (100%), WDA 18%, WDA 6% and FYA 100% for your asset. Year-by-year relief tables, NPV comparison, and best-option recommendation.
Compare Capital Allowances
Capital Allowances Comparison Explained
All capital allowances ultimately provide the same total relief: cost minus disposal proceeds. The difference is timing — when you receive the tax saving. Front-loaded allowances (AIA, FYA) give relief in year one; WDA spreads it over many years. NPV comparison quantifies the cash-flow advantage of earlier relief.
Priority Order for Capital Allowances
For best results: (1) Use FYA on qualifying zero-emission/green assets — preserves AIA limit. (2) Use AIA on special rate pool assets first (6% WDA otherwise). (3) Use AIA on main pool assets (18% WDA otherwise). (4) Fall back to WDA only when AIA/FYA is unavailable or exhausted. Cars can only use WDA (or FYA for zero-emission).
The NPV Advantage Explained
The NPV advantage of AIA over WDA is larger when: the discount rate is high (money is more valuable sooner), the WDA rate is low (6% vs 18%), and the holding period is long (WDA accumulates slowly). The comparison calculator shows the exact NPV for your specific inputs.
Frequently Asked Questions
The main options are: AIA (100% year-one, up to £1 million), FYA 100% (qualifying green assets, no cap), WDA 18% (main pool reducing balance), WDA 6% (special rate pool), and Full Expensing for companies (100% main pool, 50% special rate, no cap — companies only from April 2023).
AIA and FYA (both 100% year-one) give the highest NPV of tax relief because they front-load the deduction. Total relief is the same under all allowances — only timing differs. The NPV comparison in this calculator quantifies the cash flow advantage.
WDA is used when: the asset is a car (AIA not available for cars), qualifying expenditure exceeds the £1 million AIA limit, or the business chooses not to claim AIA. Cars use WDA 18% (50g/km or less) or 6% (above 50g/km), or 100% FYA if zero-emission.
NPV discounts future tax savings to present value, accounting for the time value of money. A £1 saving today is worth more than £1 in 10 years. AIA concentrates the saving in year 1, giving a higher NPV than WDA which spreads savings over many years. This calculator shows exact NPV for each scenario.
Special rate pool assets at 6% WDA: cars with CO2 above 50g/km, integral features (electrical systems, heating, lifts, cold water), long-life assets (useful life over 25 years), and thermal insulation. AIA can be claimed on integral features and long-life assets — use it on these first (6% otherwise is very slow relief).
From April 2023, companies can claim 100% first-year allowance on new main pool assets (Full Expensing) with no £1 million cap, and 50% FYA on new special rate assets. Companies only — not sole traders or partnerships. Gives same year-one relief as AIA for main pool, and better than 6% WDA for special rate.
Use 100% FYA for new zero-emission cars (0g/km CO2, registered from April 2021). This gives full cost deduction in year one. Use FYA rather than AIA to preserve the AIA limit for other plant and machinery that doesn't qualify for FYA.
Cars with CO2 above 50g/km can only use 6% WDA (special rate pool). No AIA, no FYA available. This makes high-emission cars the least tax-efficient business vehicle purchase — a strong incentive to switch to zero-emission vehicles with 100% FYA.
Yes. Total net relief = (cost minus disposal proceeds) x tax rate — regardless of which allowance is used. If AIA was claimed (100% year 1) and asset sold for £20,000, a balancing charge of £20,000 arises at disposal. Net relief = cost minus £20,000. The benefit of AIA is timing (earlier relief) not greater total relief.
Prioritise AIA on: (1) special rate assets first (6% WDA otherwise — biggest NPV benefit), then (2) main pool assets (18% WDA otherwise). Use FYA on qualifying zero-emission/green assets instead of AIA to preserve the AIA limit for other assets.
Yes. In any tax year you can claim AIA on some qualifying assets, FYA on qualifying green assets, and WDA on remaining pool balances. Each allowance applies per asset. The key rule: AIA and FYA cannot both apply to the same asset, and cars use WDA (or FYA for zero-emission only).
Because earlier money is more valuable. AIA gives the same total saving as WDA but concentrated in year one. Discounting future cash flows (NPV) shows the AIA early payment is worth more in present-value terms. The discount rate quantifies exactly how much more valuable the earlier relief is.