With dozens of lenders offering personal loans in the UK, comparing options can feel overwhelming. This guide explains how to properly compare loans, understand the true cost of borrowing, and make an informed decision that could save you hundreds or even thousands of pounds.
Understanding APR: The Key Comparison Tool
APR (Annual Percentage Rate) is mandated by UK law specifically to help consumers compare loans. Unlike the basic interest rate, APR includes:
- The interest rate charged on the loan
- Any mandatory arrangement fees
- Payment protection insurance (if required)
- Administration charges
Try Our Free Loan Calculator
Get instant results with our Loan Calculator. Also check our Mortgage Calculator and Interest Rate Calculator.
How to Calculate Monthly Loan Payments
Most personal loans use the reducing balance method, where interest is charged on the remaining balance:
M = P × [r(1+r)^n] / [(1+r)^n - 1]
Where: M = monthly payment, P = principal (loan amount), r = monthly interest rate (APR ÷ 12 ÷ 100), n = number of months
Example: £10,000 Loan at 7% APR over 5 Years
Loan amount: £10,000
APR: 7% (monthly rate = 0.5833%)
Term: 60 months
Monthly payment: £198.01
Total repayment: £11,880.60
Total interest: £1,880.60
Loan Comparison: Same Amount, Different Terms
See how the loan term affects your costs for a £10,000 loan at 7% APR:
| Loan Term | Monthly Payment | Total Interest | Total Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 years (24 months) | £447.73 | £745.52 | £10,745.52 |
| 3 years (36 months) | £308.77 | £1,115.72 | £11,115.72 |
| 5 years (60 months) | £198.01 | £1,880.60 | £11,880.60 |
| 7 years (84 months) | £150.93 | £2,678.12 | £12,678.12 |
Comparing Different Lenders
Here's how a £15,000 loan over 5 years compares across different APR rates:
| Lender APR | Monthly Payment | Total Interest | vs Lowest Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.9% APR | £289.35 | £2,361.00 | Best deal |
| 7.9% APR | £302.76 | £3,165.60 | +£804.60 |
| 9.9% APR | £316.51 | £3,990.60 | +£1,629.60 |
| 12.9% APR | £338.73 | £5,323.80 | +£2,962.80 |
Types of Personal Loans
Unsecured Personal Loans
The most common type in the UK. No collateral required, but rates depend heavily on your credit score. Typical APR ranges from 3% (excellent credit) to 30%+ (poor credit).
Secured Loans
Secured against your home or other asset. Lower rates possible, but your property is at risk if you can't repay. Usually for larger amounts (£10,000+).
Guarantor Loans
Someone else guarantees your repayments. Useful if you have poor credit, but your guarantor becomes liable if you default.
What Affects Your Loan Rate?
- Credit score: The biggest factor. Scores above 700 (Experian) typically get the best rates
- Loan amount: Rates often vary by amount. £7,500-£15,000 often has better rates than smaller loans
- Employment status: Permanent employment preferred over self-employment or temporary contracts
- Existing debt: High debt-to-income ratio increases your rate
- Loan term: Some lenders offer better rates for certain term lengths
Hidden Costs to Watch For
- Early repayment charges: Some lenders charge 1-2 months' interest if you pay off early
- Late payment fees: Typically £12-£25 per missed payment plus damaged credit
- Payment protection insurance: Optional but often pushed at application
- Arrangement fees: Should be included in APR but double-check
Loan Comparison Checklist
- Check your credit score before applying
- Use eligibility checkers to see pre-approved rates
- Compare representative APR across lenders
- Calculate total cost, not just monthly payments
- Check early repayment terms
- Read reviews about customer service
- Consider overpayment flexibility
- Apply to your best option only
Real-World Comparison Example
Sarah needs to borrow £8,000 for home improvements. She compares three lenders:
Bank A: 6.9% APR, £236.89/month, 36 months = £8,528 total
Bank B: 5.4% APR, £230.21/month, 36 months = £8,288 total
Bank C: 4.9% APR, £227.45/month, 36 months = £8,188 total
Saving: Bank C saves Sarah £340 compared to Bank A
When to Avoid Borrowing
A loan isn't always the right choice. Consider alternatives:
- 0% credit cards: For purchases under £5,000, a 0% purchase card may be cheaper
- Savings: If you can wait, saving avoids interest entirely
- Overdraft: For very short-term needs (under 1 month)
- Credit union loans: Often lower rates for members, especially for smaller amounts
How Loan Interest Is Calculated in the UK
Understanding how interest accrues on a loan helps you evaluate whether a borrowing decision makes financial sense. Most UK personal loans use a reducing balance method, where interest is calculated on the outstanding principal each month rather than on the original loan amount. This means that your early repayments are predominantly interest, with the proportion shifting towards capital repayment as the loan matures. On a £10,000 loan at 5 percent APR over 5 years, you would pay approximately £1,323 in total interest, with monthly payments of £188.71.
The Annual Percentage Rate (APR) is the key comparison figure for UK loans, as it includes all mandatory charges including interest and any compulsory fees, expressed as an annual rate. Under UK consumer credit regulations, lenders must display a representative APR that at least 51 percent of successful applicants receive. This means that up to 49 percent of approved borrowers may receive a higher rate based on their credit profile. Your actual rate depends on factors including your credit score, income, existing debts, and the loan amount and term.
The total cost of credit, rather than the monthly payment, should be your primary comparison metric. A loan with a lower monthly payment but longer term may cost significantly more in total interest than a higher monthly payment over a shorter period. For example, £15,000 at 6 percent APR costs £2,360 in interest over 3 years (monthly payment £456), but £4,830 in interest over 5 years (monthly payment £330). The five-year option saves £126 per month but costs £2,470 more overall. Always weigh affordability against total cost when choosing a loan term.
Types of Loans Available in the UK
The UK lending market offers several types of personal loans, each suited to different circumstances. Unsecured personal loans, available from £1,000 to £50,000 from most high street banks, are the most common type and do not require you to put up assets as collateral. Secured loans are backed by an asset (usually your home) and typically offer lower interest rates but carry the risk of losing the asset if you default. The lowest rates are generally available on loans between £7,500 and £15,000 over 3 to 5 years, as this is the sweet spot where lenders compete most aggressively.
Credit unions, which are regulated by the Prudential Regulation Authority in the UK, offer an alternative to mainstream lenders, particularly for smaller loan amounts or borrowers with less-than-perfect credit histories. Credit union loan rates are capped at 42.6 percent APR (3 percent per month), but typical rates are far lower, often between 5 and 15 percent APR. Membership is usually based on a common bond such as living in a particular area, working for a specific employer, or belonging to a particular community group. There are over 400 credit unions in the UK serving approximately 2 million members.
Government-backed loans are available for specific purposes. The Start Up Loans scheme provides personal loans of up to £25,000 at 6 percent fixed interest for new business owners. Student loans for tuition and maintenance operate under unique terms with income-contingent repayment. Help to Save accounts, while not loans, provide government bonuses of 50 percent on savings for eligible low-income households, which can be more beneficial than borrowing for smaller purchases.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does comparing loans affect my credit score?
Using eligibility checkers and comparison tools that perform soft credit searches does not affect your credit score. Most major UK comparison sites, including MoneySuperMarket, Compare the Market, and ClearScore, use soft searches that are visible only to you. However, making a formal loan application triggers a hard credit search, which is visible to other lenders and can temporarily reduce your credit score. For this reason, use soft-search eligibility tools to narrow your options before making a single formal application to your preferred lender.
Can I pay off a UK personal loan early?
Yes, you have the right to repay a UK personal loan early at any time under the Consumer Credit Act. The lender may charge an early repayment fee of up to 58 days' additional interest if more than 12 months remain on the loan, or 28 days' interest if 12 months or less remain. Many lenders waive early repayment charges entirely. Paying off a loan early saves interest and can improve your debt-to-income ratio, which may help with future credit applications. Always request a settlement figure from your lender, as this will be lower than simply adding up the remaining monthly payments.
What is the best loan amount for the lowest interest rate?
UK lenders typically offer their lowest representative APR on loans between £7,500 and £15,000 over 3 to 5 years. Loans below £5,000 and above £25,000 tend to carry higher rates. If you need to borrow £6,500, it may be worth borrowing £7,500 to access a lower rate, provided you immediately overpay the excess £1,000 against the balance. However, always check that the total interest paid on the larger loan at the lower rate is genuinely less than on the smaller loan at the higher rate, as this is not always the case.
Comparing Loans in the UK Financial Market
The UK personal loan market is highly competitive, with dozens of banks, building societies, and specialist lenders offering unsecured personal loans. Interest rates vary significantly between providers and are heavily influenced by the borrower's credit score, the loan amount, and the repayment term. As of 2025/26, the most competitive UK personal loan rates for borrowers with excellent credit histories are in the range of 3 to 6 percent APR for amounts between 7,500 and 25,000 pounds. Smaller loans (under 5,000 pounds) and larger loans (over 25,000 pounds) typically attract higher rates due to different risk profiles.
The FCA requires UK lenders to advertise a representative APR, which must be offered to at least 51 percent of successful applicants. This means that up to 49 percent of approved borrowers may receive a higher rate than advertised. This is why loan comparison is so important: the rate you are actually offered may differ from the headline rate you see on comparison websites. Many UK comparison sites, including MoneySupermarket, Compare the Market, and Confused.com, now offer soft-search eligibility tools that show your likely rate without affecting your credit score, making it easier to compare real rather than representative rates before committing to a full application.
Building societies and credit unions are often overlooked alternatives to mainstream bank loans in the UK. There are over 400 credit unions operating across the UK, serving approximately 2 million members. Credit unions are not-for-profit financial cooperatives regulated by the FCA, and they cap their interest rates at 42.6 percent APR by law, making them a significantly cheaper alternative to payday lenders for those who cannot access mainstream credit. Some credit unions offer rates comparable to high-street banks for borrowers with moderate credit histories. Building societies, while more commonly associated with mortgages and savings, also offer personal loans with competitive rates, and their mutual ownership structure means profits are returned to members rather than shareholders.
Practical Tips for Comparing UK Loans
- Compare total repayable amounts: A loan at 5% APR over 5 years costs more in total interest than the same loan at 6% APR over 3 years. Always compare the total amount repayable, not just the monthly payment or APR in isolation.
- Check multiple comparison sites: No single UK comparison website covers every lender. Use at least two or three, and also check direct offers from your own bank or building society, which may offer preferential rates to existing customers.
- Consider the loan sweet spot: UK personal loan rates are typically lowest for amounts between 7,500 and 15,000 pounds. If you need to borrow slightly less than 7,500 pounds, check whether borrowing exactly 7,500 pounds at a lower rate would actually cost less in total interest.
More Questions About Comparing Loans
Does checking loan rates affect my UK credit score?
What is the difference between a secured and unsecured loan in the UK?
Should I consolidate multiple debts into one UK loan?
James Mitchell, ACCA
Chartered Accountant & Former HMRC Advisor
James is a Chartered Certified Accountant (ACCA) specialising in UK personal taxation and financial planning. With over 12 years in practice and a background as a former HMRC compliance officer, he brings authoritative insight to complex tax topics.